As part of its commitment to tracking real-time sentiment and market direction, Steel Industry News conducted its latest Community Pricing Poll in May 2025, inviting industry professionals to weigh in on a simple but critical question: Where do you think steel prices are heading in the next 3–6 months?
This article will provide a comprehensive, data-driven analysis of the poll results, industry commentary, and market fundamentals. We’ll compare the May poll with April’s findings, explore the reasoning behind each viewpoint, and examine what these insights mean for businesses, buyers, and suppliers navigating the steel market’s uncertain terrain.
Steel Industry News Community Poll: May 2025 Results
The May 2025 poll drew 282 votes from a diverse cross-section of the steel community. Here’s how the votes broke down:
- 📉 Going Down: 38%
- 📈 Going Up: 37%
- ⚖️ Staying Stable: 26%
This near-even split underscores the deep uncertainty and debate within the sector. While more expected prices to decline, nearly as many foresee an increase, and a significant minority predicts stability.
Poll Results Table: May 2025
| Direction | Percentage | Number of Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Going Down | 38% | 107 |
| Going Up | 37% | 104 |
| Staying Stable | 26% | 71 |
| Total | 100% | 282 |
Comparing April vs. May: Shifting Sentiment in the Steel Community
To put the May results in context, let’s revisit the April 2025 Steel Industry News Community Poll1. That poll, with 565 responses, reflected a slightly different sentiment:
- Going Up: 47%
- Going Down: 29%
- Staying Stable: 22%
Poll Results Comparison Table: April vs. May 2025
| Month | Going Up | Going Down | Staying Stable | Total Votes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| April | 47% | 29% | 22% | 565 |
| May | 37% | 38% | 26% | 282 |
Key Takeaways:
- Bullish sentiment (expecting price increases) dropped by 10 percentage points from April to May.
- Bearish sentiment (expecting price decreases) rose sharply by 9 percentage points.
- The “stable” camp grew modestly, suggesting more respondents see a new equilibrium or plateau emerging.
The comparison between our May and April Steel Industry News Community Pricing Polls reveals a pronounced and telling shift in market sentiment—a reflection of just how quickly the landscape can change in the steel industry. In April, our poll captured a distinctly bullish mood: 47% of respondents expected steel prices to rise, while only 29% anticipated a decline and 22% predicted stability. This optimism was largely driven by persistent cost pressures—rising raw material and energy costs, strong scrap markets, and the impact of tariffs—which allowed mills to maintain higher prices even as some demand signals softened. As highlighted in our April coverage, many participants pointed to ongoing infrastructure spending and supply constraints as reasons to believe the price rally would continue.
However, by May, our poll results told a very different story. The share of respondents expecting prices to fall jumped to 38%, nearly matching the 37% who still foresaw increases, while the “stable” camp grew to 26%. This near-even split is a stark contrast to April’s clear bullish majority and signals growing uncertainty and caution within the community. Several factors contributed to this shift. Notably, after months of steady price hikes, major producers like Nucor enacted price reductions in May, marking a significant inflection point and suggesting that mills are now prioritizing volume and customer relationships over further price gains. Market data also revealed uneven demand across sectors and regions, with service center shipments softening and scrap prices tumbling after a period of strength, further undermining bullish expectations.
What’s Driving the Debate? Industry Voices and Market Fundamentals
Steel price forecasts are never simple. They are shaped by a complex web of supply-demand dynamics, raw material costs, policy shifts, and global events. Let’s break down the core arguments from each camp, drawing on poll comments, market data, and recent news.
1. The Bearish Case: Why Many Expect Steel Prices to Fall
Key Factors Behind Bearish Sentiment
- Weakening Demand:
- Major steel-consuming sectors like automotive and agriculture are struggling. U.S. automotive production dropped 12% in March, and agricultural equipment demand remains soft.
- The Chinese property sector, a major global steel driver, continues to face a downturn, pushing excess Chinese steel into export markets and suppressing global prices.
- Global Oversupply:
- Global steel capacity utilization fell below 75% in early 2025, compared to 77.3% at the end of 2024, indicating persistent oversupply.
- New electric arc furnace (EAF) capacity in the U.S. (+2.4 million tons) adds to the supply glut1.
- Macroeconomic Headwinds:
- S&P Global and Market Consulting Intelligence (MCI) both forecast a decline in steel prices through mid- to late-2025, with the next cyclical trough expected before a gradual recovery in 2027.
- Trade Policy Uncertainty:
- The announcement of a 25% tariff on all steel imports into the U.S. in February 2025 may redirect surplus global steel to Europe and the Middle East, further weighing on prices outside the U.S..
Supporting Data: Demand and Supply Indicators
| Indicator | Recent Trend |
|---|---|
| U.S. Automotive Production | Down 12% in March |
| Agricultural Equipment Demand | Weakening |
| Global Steel Demand (2025) | Up 1.2% (modest) |
| Global Capacity Utilization | Below 75% |
| New EAF Capacity (U.S.) | +2.4 million tons |
The Bullish Case: Why Some Expect Steel Prices to Rise
Despite the growing chorus of bearish voices, a significant portion of the Steel Industry News Community—37% in the May 2025 poll—believes that steel prices are poised to increase over the next 3–6 months. This optimism is not unfounded and is rooted in several compelling market trends and structural shifts.
Key Drivers of Bullish Sentiment
- Robust Scrap Metal Market:
The ferrous scrap market has seen three consecutive months of price increases, with Chicago’s prime scrap grades reaching $475 per gross ton in March 2025—a 25% rise over three months. This surge is driven by supply constraints and robust mill demand, especially as new electric arc furnace (EAF) capacity comes online. The resulting competition for scrap is expected to keep prices elevated, supporting higher finished steel prices. - Capacity Expansion and Modernization:
Major steelmakers are investing heavily in modernization and capacity expansion to meet global demand. Companies like ArcelorMittal and thyssenkrupp AG are focusing on innovation, sustainability, and efficiency, which enhances their ability to respond to market shifts and capitalize on price upswings2. - Sustained Global Demand:
While some sectors are soft, global steel demand is projected to grow at a 4.6% CAGR through 2030, fueled by infrastructure, urbanization, and the transition to electric vehicles. The construction and renewable energy sectors, in particular, are expected to drive significant steel consumption as governments and industries invest in green infrastructure and energy transition projects. - Supply Chain Tightness and Trade Barriers:
Ongoing trade tensions, tariffs, and anti-dumping measures are constraining imports in several regions, tightening supply and potentially creating upward pressure on domestic prices. For example, the U.S. 25% tariff on steel imports has shifted global trade flows and could lead to localized shortages, especially if global production cuts materialize as forecasted. - Sustainability and Green Steel Premiums:
The industry’s pivot toward low-carbon and recycled steel products is creating new market segments where buyers are willing to pay a premium for sustainable materials. This trend is expected to support price resilience, particularly for high-performance and specialty steels.
The Case for Stability: Why Some See Steel Prices Holding Steady
A notable 26% of poll respondents believe that steel prices will remain stable over the next 3–6 months. This outlook is informed by a balance of opposing market forces and a belief that the current price range represents a new equilibrium.
Factors Supporting Price Stability
- Offsetting Market Pressures:
While demand in some sectors is softening, other areas—such as infrastructure and renewables—are picking up the slack. This balancing act could keep prices from swinging dramatically in either direction5. - Inventory Management:
Many buyers and end-users are managing inventories conservatively, having learned from the volatility of the past two years. This disciplined approach helps dampen price swings and supports a stable market environment. - Monetary Policy and Macroeconomic Trends:
Central banks, including the European Central Bank, have begun easing monetary policy, which could gradually support economic growth and steel demand. However, the effects of these policy changes are expected to be slow to materialize, contributing to a period of relative price stability5. - Structural Changes in Production:
The adoption of EAF and DRI technologies, along with increased recycling, is making steel production more flexible and responsive to market changes. This adaptability can help cushion the market against sharp supply shocks and price volatility2.
Community Insights: What Industry Voices Are Saying
The Steel Industry News Community poll is more than just numbers—it’s a reflection of real-world sentiment and on-the-ground experience. Here’s a sample of the comments and perspectives shared by respondents:
- “With decreasing demand, I would be particularly interested in this answer too.”
— Tamás Prokaj, referencing the importance of demand-side dynamics. - “The scrap market has been on a tear, and with new EAF mills coming online, I expect prices to hold firm even if demand softens.”
— Anonymous poll participant - “Tariffs and trade policies are making it harder to predict where prices will go, but I don’t see a major crash or spike in the near term.”
—Poll participant
Steel Industry News Community Polls: What They Reveal About Market Sentiment
The May 2025 poll, when compared with April’s results, highlights a notable shift in sentiment:
- Bullish sentiment has weakened, while bearish sentiment has grown.
- A larger share of respondents now expect stability, reflecting a more cautious or wait-and-see approach.
Looking Ahead: What Should the Steel Community Watch For?
As we move into the second half of 2025, several key factors will determine the trajectory of steel prices:
- Global economic recovery and industrial output: Will recent monetary easing and government stimulus translate into stronger demand?
- Supply chain resilience: Can mills and suppliers adapt to ongoing disruptions and shifting trade flows?
- Sustainability and innovation: Will investments in green steel and digital transformation pay off in terms of market share and pricing power?
- Geopolitical and trade policy developments: How will tariffs, anti-dumping measures, and regional conflicts impact global supply and demand?
Conclusion: Navigating Uncertainty in the Steel Industry
The May 2025 Steel Industry News Community Pricing Poll reveals a market at a crossroads. With nearly equal shares of respondents expecting prices to rise or fall, and a significant minority predicting stability, the steel industry faces a period of heightened uncertainty and debate.
Key takeaways for industry stakeholders:
- Stay informed: Regularly monitor market data, community sentiment, and policy developments.
- Diversify sourcing and sales strategies: Prepare for both upside and downside scenarios.
- Invest in sustainability and innovation: Position your business for long-term resilience and growth.
Check out our Steel Industry News podcast (a subscriber only benefit) :
Check out some of our other articles:
- Steel Industry News Community Poll: Reactions To The 50% Steel Tariffs
- Nucor Raises Prices as 50% Tariffs Reshape Market Dynamics
- Cleveland-Cliffs Cancels $500 Million Green Steel Project
- Trump Announces New 50% Steel and Aluminum Tariffs
- The US Steel-Nippon Steel Deal: Structure, National Security, and the “Golden Share”
📬 Enjoying this article? Don’t miss the next one.
Subscribe to the Steel Industry News email newsletter to get the latest updates delivered straight to your inbox — from mill pricing to market shifts.🆓 Stay informed with a free subscription, or
🔐 Unlock even more with a paid plan (just $10.50/month with annual billing) and get:✅ Full access to all in-depth newsletters and podcasts
📊 U.S. mill pricing, input costs, and production data
🌍 The latest Steel Industry News direct to you
📚 Exclusive subscriber-only E-Books, reports, guides & archives
🙌 Unlock Full Access to the Steel Market Insights & Strategy Guide
