Understanding the Trade Petition
Steel Dynamics, Inc. (SDI), Nucor, U.S. Steel, Wheeling Nippon Steel, USW Union have recently filed a trade petition with the U.S. Department of Commerce (DOC) and the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) seeking antidumping and countervailing duties on imports of corrosion-resistant flat rolled steel (CORE) from 10 countries. This move is a significant step in protecting the domestic steel industry from what SDI perceives as unfair trade practices.
What is Corrosion-Resistant Flat Rolled Steel (CORE)?
CORE is a type of steel that has been coated with zinc, or in some cases aluminum, to make it resistant to corrosion. This property makes it highly desirable for a variety of applications, including:
- Automotive: Used in components like car bodies, doors, and hoods.
- Appliances: Found in refrigerators, washing machines, and other household appliances.
- Construction: Utilized in building materials such as roofing, siding, and gutters.
The U.S. market for CORE is substantial, with annual demand exceeding 20 million tons.
The Case for Trade Duties
The organizations argue that imports of CORE from the subject countries have surged in recent years, negatively impacting domestic producers. They contend that these imports are being sold below fair market value (dumping) or are subsidized by foreign governments (countervailing). The companies are seeking to apply antidumping duties against imports of corrosion resistant flat rolled steel (CORE) from Australia, Brazil, Canada, Mexico, The Netherlands, South Africa, Taiwan, Turkey, UAE, and Vietnam, and countervailing duties against imports of CORE from Brazil, Canada, Mexico, and Vietnam.
The filers suggest that Brazil, Canada, Mexico, and Vietnam, have both dumped material as well as have been unfairly subsidized.
Allegations against Australia, the Netherlands, South Africa, Turkey, and the UAE, are for unfairly dumped material.
The key points raised by SDI include:
- Increased Imports: The volume of CORE imports has grown significantly, putting pressure on domestic prices and market share. “Between the first half of 2023 and the first half of 2024, imports of CORE from the ten subject countries surged from less than 1.25 million tons to almost two million tons, a significant 57 percent increase. The surge of unfairly traded imports of CORE has had a significant negative impact on the domestic steel industry’s volume, prices, and profits, necessitating these cases,” said Barry T. Schneider, President and Chief Operating Officer.
- Price Undercutting: Foreign producers are allegedly selling CORE in the U.S. market at prices below their production costs.
- Government Subsidies: Some countries are providing financial assistance to their CORE producers, giving them an unfair advantage.
- Negative Impact on Domestic Industry: The influx of unfairly traded imports has harmed the domestic steel industry, leading to job losses and reduced profits.
The Economic Implications
The outcome of this trade petition could have far-reaching implications for the U.S. steel industry. If the DOC and ITC determine that the imports are being dumped or subsidized, duties could be imposed on these products. This would make them more expensive for U.S. consumers, potentially leading to:
- Increased Costs for Domestic Goods: Manufacturers that use CORE in their products may face higher input costs, which could be passed on to consumers in the form of higher prices.
- Job Creation and Retention: If duties are imposed, it could help to protect domestic jobs in the steel industry and related sectors.
- Retaliation from Trading Partners: Other countries may retaliate by imposing their own tariffs on U.S. exports, leading to a trade war.
- Trade Risk: It remains to be seen whether the duties and penalties from the DOC and ITC investigations will be applied retroactively.
The Road Ahead
The trade petition process is complex and time-consuming. The DOC will investigate whether the imports are being dumped or subsidized, while the ITC will assess the impact on the domestic industry. Barry Schneider, SDI President and Chief Operating Officer. “Under the unfair trade statutes, the DOC must determine whether to initiate the requested investigations within 20 days, and the ITC must make a preliminary determination of injury within 45 days. Subject to initiation, the company expects preliminary determinations on subsidies later this year and on dumping early next year, though these determinations are subject to extension. Final rulings by both agencies should be completed by October 2025,”
The outcome of this case will have a significant impact on the future of the U.S. CORE market. If duties are imposed, it could help to level the playing field for domestic producers, but it could also lead to higher prices for consumers. The trade dispute between SDI and the foreign producers is likely to be closely watched by policymakers, businesses, and consumers alike.
For the latest steel news updates on Steel Pricing and other steel trends, be sure to follow Steel Industry News
Check out some of our other articles on the Steel Market:
Vietnam’s Steel Industry Under Pressure: A Perfect Storm of Trade Disputes
Steel Pricing Update: Nucor and Cleveland-Cliffs Lead the Way
Nucor CSP Price Update: Downward Trend Continues
Summer Slowdown: Exploring the Factors Behind the Steel Market Downturn
Steel Prices Slide: Nucor CSP Dips Again, Construction Slowdown a Potential Culprit
Steel Price Update: Nucor CSP Dips, Cleveland Cliffs Follows With August Price Decrease
Steel Prices Continue Decline Pressured By Housing Market Slowdown
Nucor’s CSP: A Game Changer in Steel Price Transparency?
Be sure to subscribe to the Free Steel Industry Newsletter for the latest steel related news direct to your inbox!
