The US market is currently navigating turbulent waters as consumer confidence plummets to concerning levels while steel imports experience significant volatility influenced by recent tariff implementations. Consumer sentiment has declined for four consecutive months through March 2025, with expectations for the future hitting a 12-year low—a troubling indicator that historically signals recession risks. Meanwhile, steel imports surged in January before dropping dramatically in February following the announcement of expanded Section 232 tariffs.
Consumer Confidence in Freefall: Fourth Consecutive Monthly Decline
Consumer confidence in the United States has deteriorated significantly in early 2025, with March marking the fourth straight month of decline. According to The Conference Board, the Consumer Confidence Index fell by 7.2 points in March to 92.9, continuing a troubling downward trend that began in December 20244. This decline was more severe than analysts had anticipated, as they had projected a more modest drop to 94.5 based on FactSet survey data7. The consistent erosion of consumer sentiment throughout the first quarter of 2025 represents a marked departure from the relatively stable pattern observed throughout most of 2022-2024, signaling a potential shift in the economic outlook.
The decline in consumer confidence is even more concerning when examining its component indices. The Present Situation Index, which measures consumers’ assessment of current business and labor market conditions, decreased by 3.6 points to 134.5 in March4. While this represents a significant decline, the real alarm comes from the Expectations Index, which plummeted by 9.6 points to reach 65.2—its lowest level in 12 years4. This reading is particularly troubling because economists at The Conference Board consider an Expectations Index below 80 to be a warning signal that a recession may be on the horizon. The current reading of 65.2 is well below this critical threshold, suggesting that consumers are increasingly pessimistic about their economic futures.
Parallel data from the University of Michigan’s Consumer Sentiment Index reinforces this negative trend. Their measure was revised lower to 57 in March 2025 from a preliminary estimate of 57.9, representing a substantial drop from February’s reading of 64.71. This marks the third consecutive monthly decline in this alternative measure of consumer sentiment, with the current reading at its lowest point since November 20221. The consistency between these two major consumer confidence indicators underscores the breadth and depth of consumer pessimism permeating the US economy.
Drivers of Consumer Pessimism: Inflation, Unemployment, and Policy Uncertainty
The deterioration in consumer confidence can be attributed to several interconnected factors weighing on Americans’ economic outlook. Inflation expectations have surged dramatically, with the University of Michigan survey showing that consumers now anticipate inflation over the year ahead to exceed 5%—the highest reading since November 20221. This represents a significant increase from the 4.3% recorded in February, reflecting growing consumer anxiety about rising prices4. Long-term inflation expectations have also increased, with the five-year outlook revised higher to 4.1% from 3.9% in the preliminary estimate1.
Unemployment concerns have emerged as another major contributor to falling consumer confidence. According to the University of Michigan survey, two-thirds of consumers now expect unemployment to rise in the year ahead—the highest such reading since 2009, during the aftermath of the Global Financial Crisis1. This widespread expectation of deteriorating labor market conditions reflects a fundamental shift in how Americans view economic prospects, transitioning from the relative optimism of recent years to a more pessimistic outlook reminiscent of periods of economic distress.
The uncertainty surrounding economic policy developments, particularly regarding tariffs, has further compounded consumer anxiety. Stephanie Guichard, Senior Economist at The Conference Board, noted that “consumers’ expectations were especially gloomy, with pessimism about future business conditions deepening and confidence about future employment prospects falling to a 12-year low”4. The implementation of expanded tariffs on steel, aluminum, and other imports has contributed to this uncertainty, with consumers increasingly concerned about the potential impact on prices and overall economic conditions. Perhaps most concerning is that “consumers’ optimism about future income—which had held up quite strongly in the past few months—largely vanished,” suggesting that worries about the economy have begun to affect consumers’ assessments of their personal financial situations4.
Steel Imports: Dramatic Fluctuations in Early 2025
The American steel import market has experienced remarkable volatility in the first two months of 2025, showing a pattern that appears closely tied to tariff policy announcements. In January 2025, the United States imported a total of 3,065,000 net tons of steel, including 2,305,000 net tons of finished steel—representing increases of 43.5% and 26.5% respectively compared to December 20242. This January surge pushed total and finished steel imports up by 20.2% and 20.3% respectively compared to January 2024, suggesting initially strong import activity at the beginning of the year2. During this period, finished steel import market share was estimated at 25%, indicating that one-quarter of the steel being used in the US market was coming from foreign sources2.
February 2025, however, saw a dramatic reversal of this trend. Based on preliminary Census Bureau data reported by the American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI), total steel imports dropped to 2,235,000 net tons—a substantial 27.2% decrease from January5. Finished steel imports declined even more sharply, falling by 29.6% to 1,623,000 net tons5. This abrupt decline coincided with the mid-month announcement of expanded Section 232 tariffs, suggesting that importers and buyers rapidly adjusted their procurement strategies in anticipation of the tariff changes. Despite this monthly decline, it’s worth noting that total and finished steel imports were still up 5.7% and 7.4% respectively year-to-date versus 2024, indicating that the overall import trend remains higher than the previous year despite the February pullback5.
The import market share for finished steel products also reflected this changing dynamic, dropping from an estimated 25% in January to 22% in February, with a year-to-date average of 24% for the first two months of 20255. This fluctuation in market share demonstrates the significant impact that trade policy changes can have on steel supply chains and market dynamics in a relatively short period.
Key Steel Product Categories Showing Significant Changes
The impact of changing import patterns has varied considerably across different steel product categories. In January 2025, several key steel products showed substantial increases compared to December 2024, including heavy structural shapes (up 199%), reinforcing bars (up 191%), blooms, billets and slabs (up 143%), oil country goods (up 121%), and line pipe (up 84%)2. These dramatic increases likely reflected importers’ efforts to bring in material ahead of anticipated tariff changes.
In contrast, February’s data showed much more restrained import activity, with cut length plates being the only key steel product category showing a significant increase (up 19%) compared to January5. This selective growth in a single category amid broader declines suggests that specific market needs or supply agreements may have overridden tariff concerns for this particular product.
Looking at the longer-term trend over the 12-month period from March 2024 to February 2025, several product categories have shown significant increases compared to the previous 12-month period. These include tin plate (up 55%), sheets and strip all other metallic coated (up 33%), sheets and strip hot dipped galvanized (up 28%), wire rods (up 24%), and cold rolled sheets (up 22%)5. These sustained increases over a longer timeframe indicate structural shifts in import patterns that may reflect changing domestic production capabilities, pricing dynamics, or specific product requirements that continue to drive import demand despite tariff barriers.
Section 232 Tariffs: Expanded Impact on Steel Market and Consumer Confidence
The recent changes to Section 232 tariffs represent a significant shift in US trade policy with far-reaching implications for both the steel industry and broader economy. As of March 12, 2025, expanded Section 232 tariffs on steel and aluminum have officially taken effect, with all imports of these metals now subject to a 25% tariff3. This represents a substantial change from the previous policy framework in two key ways. First, all previous country exemptions and tariff-rate quotas have been eliminated, meaning that imports from previously exempted nations such as Canada, Mexico, the European Union, Japan, South Korea, and Australia are now subject to the full tariff rate3. Second, the tariff rate on aluminum has increased from 10% to 25%, representing a significant escalation in trade barriers for this critical industrial metal3.
These tariff changes are part of a broader set of trade policy adjustments implemented in early 2025. According to Tax Foundation analysis, these include a 20% tariff on all imports from China, a 25% tariff on all imports from Mexico (with temporary exemptions for autos and USMCA-compliant imports until April 2, 2025), and varying tariffs on imports from Canada (10% on energy and potash imports and 25% on all remaining imports, with similar temporary exemptions)6. The elimination of country exemptions for steel tariffs alone has dramatically expanded the scope of affected imports, increasing the value of steel imports subject to tariffs from $5.5 billion to $34.6 billion, and aluminum imports subject to tariffs from $6.1 billion to $18.5 billion6.
The product exclusion process for these tariffs has been terminated, meaning that previously approved exclusions are no longer valid3. This change has created significant supply chain challenges for manufacturers that had structured their procurement strategies around these exclusions, forcing rapid adjustments to material sourcing and pricing strategies. The expansion of tariff coverage to include derivative products based on steel and aluminum content has further complicated the situation, extending the impact beyond primary metals to a broader range of manufactured goods3.
Connecting Tariffs to Consumer Confidence Decline
The timing of the expanded tariffs appears closely linked to the deterioration in consumer confidence. Analysis from The Conference Board specifically notes that “the drop [in consumer confidence] was led by a 19% plunge in buying conditions for durables, in large part due to fears that tariff-induced price increases are imminent”4. This direct connection between tariff policy and consumer sentiment highlights how trade policy decisions can rapidly influence economic outlook beyond their immediate industry impact.
The University of Michigan survey similarly found that “many consumers cited the high level of uncertainty around policy and other economic factors” as a reason for declining sentiment1. The surge in inflation expectations recorded in both consumer surveys likely reflects, at least in part, concerns about how expanded tariffs will affect prices across the economy. With year-ahead inflation expectations jumping to 4.9% in the preliminary March reading—the highest since November 2022—it’s clear that consumers are anticipating significant price pressures, potentially exacerbated by the new tariff regime1.
Economic Implications and Future Outlook
The concurrent decline in consumer confidence and volatility in steel imports point to potential challenges for the US economy in the months ahead. The Expectations Index reading of 65.2 is particularly troubling as it sits well below the critical recession threshold of 80, suggesting increased risk of economic contraction4. Historical patterns indicate that when consumer expectations fall this low, household spending typically follows, potentially triggering broader economic slowdown as consumer spending accounts for approximately two-thirds of US economic activity7.
For the steel industry specifically, the short-term impact of the expanded tariffs appears to have been a significant reduction in import volumes. However, the longer-term effects will depend on how domestic production capacity responds to the changed competitive landscape, whether price increases are sustained, and how downstream industries adjust to potentially higher input costs. The Trading Economics forecast suggests that US consumer confidence is expected to remain at these lower levels in the near term (57.90 points by the end of the current quarter) before gradually recovering to around 74.00 points in 2026 and 78.00 points in 20271.
The impact on inflation remains a critical concern. With both major consumer surveys showing substantial increases in inflation expectations, there’s a risk that these expectations could become self-fulfilling if consumers accelerate purchases to avoid anticipated price increases or if businesses proactively raise prices in anticipation of higher input costs. The University of Michigan survey noted that inflation expectations for the year ahead topped 5%, while long-run inflation expectations increased to 4.1%—both representing significant increases from previous readings1.
Conclusion: Navigating Uncertain Waters in the US Market
The US market is currently at a crossroads, with consumer confidence falling to levels typically associated with economic contraction while trade policy changes create significant volatility in key industrial supply chains. The combined effect of these factors suggests increased economic uncertainty in the months ahead, with potential implications for consumer spending, industrial production, and inflation. The four consecutive months of declining consumer confidence, culminating in a 12-year low for expectations about the future, represents a clear warning signal that should not be ignored by policymakers, businesses, or investors.
Steel import patterns will likely continue to adjust to the new tariff environment, with potential ripple effects throughout manufacturing supply chains. As market participants adapt to these changes, close monitoring of both consumer sentiment and trade flows will be essential for anticipating broader economic trends. The connection between trade policy decisions and consumer confidence highlights the complex interrelationships in today’s economy and underscores the importance of considering the wider economic impact of targeted policy measures. The question becomes will steel prices change with reduced demand, even with tariffs in place?
If you enjoyed this article check out some of our other recent articles on the subject:
- Dodge Momentum Index Inches Up For the 5th Consecutive Month
- Nucor Holds Steel Pricing Steady Two Months Straight
- 📘 [New Ebook] Stoicism: Ancient Philosophy Offers Modern Solutions
- Nucor Holds CSP Price Steady For Seventh Week
- U.S. Steel Imports Drop to Record Lows
Be sure to subscribe to the Steel Industry Email Newsletter for the latest steel news direct to your inbox!
